A Penny for Your Thoughts (and Their Final Farewell?)

Exploring the legacy of the copper coin on National One Cent Day.

April 1st is not only April Fools’ Day, but it’s also National One Cent Day. Will this be one of the last ones we celebrate? Word on the street is the penny is officially heading into retirement. We’re taking a look back at the history of the one-cent piece and what a “pennies-less” world actually looks like.

A penny for your thoughts

After more than two centuries in circulation, why would the penny be forced into retirement?

The Original “Penny” Name: The official name is “one-cent piece,” but it was named after the British penny.

The first U.S. penny was issued in 1793 by the U.S. Mint and was made of pure copper.

Due to WWII, 1943 pennies were made of steel, but a few bronze pennies were mistakenly made, now worth millions.

Since 1982, pennies are actually 97.5% zinc and only 2.5% copper.

Over the past 10 years, the total production cost of the penny has risen from 1.3 cents to 3.69 cents per penny. These production costs include materials, facilities, and overhead.

How often do we actually use them versus leaving them in a jar?

Read More about the Penny Production Cessation FAQs from the U.S. Department of Treasury.

Who’s fooling who?!

While the debate rages on, the penny isn’t going anywhere just yet.

New pennies may no longer be rolling off the press, but with over 114 billion already in circulation, they aren’t disappearing overnight. The Federal Reserve is committed to keeping current supplies moving, but the ‘lifespan’ of the penny now depends on us. To help our local small businesses and retailers adapt to a ‘penny-less’ future, we encourage you to dig out those coin jars! Spending your change or bringing it into a branch for deposit helps keep the economy balanced and ensures a fair transition for everyone at the checkout counter.

While pennies remain in circulation, retailers are encouraged to continue accepting them for all cash transactions. However, as the physical supply transitions, many businesses will adopt a Standard Rounding Rule to the nearest 5 cents for cash payments.

It’s important to note that this “rounding adjustment” applies only to physical currency. Every digital transaction—from swiping your debit card to your monthly mortgage payment—remains accurate to the single cent. At BankFirst, we ensure your digital “pennies” are always accounted for, providing the precision and clarity you expect.

As we transition into this new era, your choice of payment can actually work in your favor! To keep your bottom line balanced, keep both cash and your BankFirst debit card handy.

  • The Cash Advantage: If your total ends in 1, 2, 6, or 7 cents, paying with cash gives you a “round-down” discount!

  • The Digital Guarantee: For all other totals, stick to your card or mobile wallet. This ensures you pay the exact price to the penny, avoiding any “round-up” adjustments.

Over time, these small choices add up—especially at large retailers. Being “penny-wise” has never been easier!

The “New Math” of the One-Cent Piece

Many people worry that “rounding up” will lead to hidden costs. In reality, most countries that have retired their lowest-denomination coin (like Canada and Australia) use a Fair Rounding Standard. Here’s how it works for cash:

  • Round Down: If your total ends in .01, .02, .06, or .07, you save a few cents!
  • Round Up: If your total ends in .03, .04, .08, or .09, it rounds to the nearest nickel.
  • Stay the Same: If it ends in .00 or .05, no change is needed.

The Digital Safety Net: It’s important to remember that this rounding applies only to physical cash. Every digital transaction—including your debit card, credit card, and mortgage payments—will always settle to the exact cent. Your digital “pennies” aren’t going anywhere!

Small Change, Big Impact: Giving Your Pennies a Purpose

Don’t let them gather dust in a jar. Since pennies are being phased out, let’s give them a productive “retirement”:

  • Fuel local missions: Organize or find a local organization or non-profit that is running a “coin drive”. Encourage your friends to do the same!
  • Cash them in: Bring your jars of change into your local bank branch to be counted and deposited (or donated) before the “rounding rules” become the norm at every retailer.

A penny saved is a penny earned—but a penny shared is a community strengthened.